My New Podcast (!), Prada-Caitlin & Kylie Beauty Murmurs

Hi, and welcome again to Line Sheet. We’ve obtained the newest and best magnificence intel from Rachel Strugatz as we speak (hassle her at [email protected]). She’s tackling two of our favourite household companies: LVMH and Kardashian Inc. But first, I’ve an truly thrilling announcement.
🎙️We’re launching a podcast!! It’s known as Fashion People, produced by Puck (bear in mind, the place the place I work) in partnership with the high quality of us over at Audacy. Think of FashionPeople as Line Sheet come to life on the 2 days you’re lacking Line Sheet. On Tuesdays, I’ll be joined by my favourite trade journalists and analysts to parse by way of probably the most attention-grabbing information and (accountable) gossip. Our inaugural (and I predict, frequent) visitor is the Wall Street Journal’s males’s trend columnist, Jacob Gallagher, an professional on excess of New Balance idler sneakers, I swear.
On Fridays, we’ll dig into one press-ing matter that deserves deeper examination. (First up: Why are garments so darn costly?) If you like me, love Line Sheet’s rising forged of characters, love the Puck Cinematic Universe, love podcasts, love trend, love magnificence, love offers, love critical enterprise evaluation delivered in a manner that doesn’t really feel so self-serious, or all the above (I hope all the above), please like and subscribe both right here, right here, or wherever you get your podcasts. And thanks to our launch sponsors, my women at Lyst and Netflix. I’m very excited to do advert reads.
Anyway, I’m jazzed, and I hope you’re, too. Please don’t be shy: preserve the subject and visitors recommendations coming. I’m open to concepts, actually!! Now, again to our often scheduled programming.
Mentioned on this concern: Kylie Jenner, Kylie Cosmetics, Caitlin Clark, Michael Rubin, Coty, Prada, Condé Nast, Hailey Bieber, St. John Knits, Brett Heyman, Nick Reardon, LVMH earnings, Sephora, Travis Scott, Gabrielle Katz, Anne Bancroft, and plenty of extra.


PRO TIP: Keep your inexperienced juice shut and your glam group nearer. We’ve obtained your hair, make-up, and nails dealt with. Book now utilizing the code LINESHEET and obtain 20% off your subsequent Glamsquad service.

The Prada-Caitlin craziness: By now, in the event you care, you realize that ladies’s basketball celebrity and record-breaking-ratings generator Caitlin Clark was lined in pink (and some black) Prada triangles on the WNBA draft, the place she was the primary total choose, and, in accordance with Fanatics C.E.O. (and cheesy party-thrower) Michael Rubin, bought extra jerseys on draft evening than any participant, in any sport… ever. (She will solely make $76,535 in her first season, which is insane, however let’s hope all of the incoming endorsements make up for it.) People going nuts for Clark equaled individuals going nuts for Prada, with an early evaluation of social media chatter by Launchmetrics displaying that, within the 24 hours post-draft, conversations about Prada x Clark generated an estimated $419,000 in Media Impact Value (Launchmetrics’ measurement of success, based mostly on all the pieces from the variety of posts and tags to likes feedback). Prada’s personal Instagram put up generated $95,000 in M.I.V. alone. That’s good.
So, sure, after all Prada was keen to decorate Clark. Giorgio Armani could have invented the pink carpet, however Prada made it as necessary to popular culture because the awards reveals themselves, ever since they began dressing celebrities severely in 1995, when Uma Thurman wore that seminal lavender robe and pashmina. Prada is the pondering girl’s model, they usually’ve all the time taken a cerebral strategy to this arm of the enterprise. The coolest, latest, most intellectually provocative individuals put on Prada.
So, mix the fervor surrounding Clark and Prada’s one-step-ahead-of-the-rest technique with the effectiveness of dressing athletes—a lot of whom are world stars with large, rabid followings—and you’ll perceive how Monday went down. My prediction is that athletes, already a few of luxurious’s largest marketing campaign stars, are going to embed additional into the style ecosystem, beginning with the Paris Olympics later this summer time. (Think: inventive directing gigs.)

An replace on these ambulance-chaser Instagram advertisements focusing on Condé Nast: If you learn Monday’s concern, you’ll know that there are advertisements floating round Instagram, making an attempt to persuade individuals to file an arbitration declare that posits Condé Nast was not upfront about knowledge assortment on a few of its web sites. (On Monday, I discussed the advert spotlighting Architectural Digest. But I’m discovering that most individuals obtained Bon Appétit—typically it confirmed up proper below a Bon Appétit Instagram put up! I’m certain you’ll get it, too, now that you simply’re studying this—together with some semaglutide product.) There had been some freaky Vogue ones, too. I nonetheless haven’t been focused. It’s impolite.
According to my inside sources, the corporate is taking this severely—there are a whole lot of most of these class-action recruiting efforts occurring proper now—however it also needs to be pretty simple to repair. P.S., you realize what actually works on me? The New Yorker article advertisements on Instagram Stories.

Smoke some weed in your St. John Knits gold-button jacket: Today within the things-you-really-didn’t-expect-to-ever-happen division: Lanvin Group-owned St. John Knits introduced a collaboration with Edie Parker, Brett Heyman’s purse line turned hashish firm. Heyman lined a brand new model of the “Burn Bag”—that includes a funny-if-gimmicky retractable lighter holster on the aspect—within the Orange County-based firm’s famed tweed.
If you aren’t American and/or don’t learn about St. John, it’s a conservative sportswear firm—and by sportswear, I imply the old school phrase for American ready-to-wear. The look is conventional, correct, and completely according to how a sure set of persons are dressing proper now. Both firms occur to work with publicist Gabrielle Katz, however Heyman says she obtained the thought after the women who lunch (and have been carrying St. John Knits for the reason that Reagan period) began shopping for weed pens from her Upper East Side boutique.
There’s an Anne Bancroft vibe to the entire thing. Heyman is a type of modern-era girl who lunches—she will be able to play the position but in addition has a job—and doubtless simply began carrying St. John Knits. I like that Lanvin Group isn’t making an attempt to make the model—which is doing properly, in accordance with latest earnings experiences—unnecessarily cool or one thing it isn’t. This collaboration feels very dangerous, and but, whenever you actually give it some thought, it’s not dangerous in any respect. Republicans smoke weed, too.

Notes on the LVMH earnings, Part I: LVMH’s first-quarter report was launched yesterday. They missed analyst expectations, however individuals had been fairly good about it. I made a decision to give attention to natural progress—up 2 % within the trend and leather-based items division, 3 % total—moderately than progress adjusted for forex fluctuations, as a result of I need to see if persons are shopping for extra. Turns out, they aren’t. They are simply spending extra as a result of costs have elevated.
Overall, I’d say that the group’s underperformance in China aligns with Kering’s related steering. (Kering is clearly in a extra precarious scenario since its manufacturers are trend-driven, for probably the most half, with a heightened sensitivity to downcycles.) In the U.S., aspirational clients haven’t disappeared altogether, however the pandemic behaviors aren’t returning. Louis Vuitton, which outperformed the division as an entire, is successful; Dior, notably, isn’t. Loro Piana has “wonderful momentum.”
LVMH is the bellwether for the remainder of the trade, and there are some things to ponder because the financial cycle performs out. First, it’s an election 12 months within the U.S., and the result may very properly have an effect on spending. Second, Chinese shoppers are fast to choose up tendencies they love, however they don’t seem to be going to simply purchase something that’s put in entrance of them. The backside line: For everybody who thought, by some means, gross sales had been going to be nice ceaselessly, or no less than bounce again effortlessly after final 12 months’s “correction,” the world doesn’t work like that. LVMH is best positioned than most to sail by way of unscathed. For those that aren’t, it’s going to be a tough few months no less than.

Notes on the LVMH earnings, Part II, starring Rachel: Beauty total, and particularly Sephora, stays a perennial vivid spot for LVMH. In January, the posh big acknowledged that the retailer’s U.S. enterprise had been distinctive in 2023, and unsurprisingly, this momentum has continued into 2024. LVMH touted “outstanding progress” at Sephora, contributing to an 11 % improve on an natural foundation for the Selective Retailing division, citing energy within the U.S., Europe, and the Middle East. Finally, the retailer will give attention to the U.Ok., a market starved for stand-alone magnificence shops, by opening three extra doorways this 12 months, bringing the full door rely to 5.
LVMH introduced final month that Sephora was exiting Korea, a “very aggressive market,” however famous that this operational choice didn’t mirror their total view on the APAC area. LVMH remains to be “extraordinarily hopeful” about China, okay? Duty free nonetheless hasn’t recovered from Covid, however Sephora and a few very robust perfume gross sales could also be sufficient to choose up the slack. Dior’s magnificence enterprise is “wonderful,” the other of its efficiency in trend. As anticipated, Dior perfumes (Sauvage, J’adore, and Miss Dior) proceed to fly off the cabinets, and Maison Francis Kurkdjian’s wildly overpowering Baccarat Rouge 540 stays wildly well-liked. —Rachel Strugatz

The Kylie Beauty Konundrum

Nearly a decade after her preliminary success, Kylie Jenner’s model is outdated and her ways have been mainstreamed. So what’s a Kardashian to do?

We’ve reached the purpose within the devolution of the human species the place unfounded rumors concerning the alleged impecuniousness of Kylie Jenner—next-gen Kardashian, licensed centimillionaire (however not billionaire), and cosmetics entrepreneur par excellence—have invaded TikTookay with ferocious velocity. The first installment of a extremely unbelievable three-part collection, “The Disastrous Demise of Kylie Cosmetics,” has amassed greater than 9 million views. Creator Nick Reardon, host of podcast Share Your Screen, makes a purely unconvincing case that the 26-year-old is nearing monetary destroy—citing the counterintuitive incontrovertible fact that she “out of nowhere launched three companies’” within the final a number of months, together with Spritzer, a canned vodka soda; Khy, a Wardrobe.NYC-esque clothes line; and a fragrance (which is definitely a part of her current magnificence enterprise). Other non-evidence consists of Jenner reducing the record worth of her Beverly Hills residence—the one she owned with Travis Scott, which has been on and off the market since they broke up—from $21.9 million to $17.9 million.
Internet theories are foolish, however I believe the newest spate of crackpottery is said to the truth that one thing positively is occurring along with her model. She’s within the midst of “stripping down” her picture, she advised The New York Times final month, and it’s obvious that Jenner’s nonetheless making an attempt to determine what to do with Kylie Cosmetics, which has misplaced momentum since its launch virtually a decade in the past. Also, Jenner’s relationship with magnificence, together with the model she helms and the methods she’s manipulated her bodily look over time, stays difficult.


PRO TIP: Keep your inexperienced juice shut and your glam group nearer. We’ve obtained your hair, make-up, and nails dealt with. Book now utilizing the code LINESHEET and obtain 20% off your subsequent Glamsquad service.

Jenner, after all, achieved extra success as a magnificence entrepreneur by age 18 than most founders will in a lifetime. Without being hyperbolic, she revolutionized the way in which the trendy superstar magnificence model was constructed (on-line), marketed (the social media “drop” mannequin), and bought (D.T.C.-to-retail). The preliminary success of her Kylie Lip Kits helped craft a playbook that also defines the trade and has impressed innumerable different celebrities to market nonsense make-up, skincare, physique care, and wellness strains.
I’ve chronicled Jenner’s magnificence enterprise extensively over time, documenting her spectacular arc of successes, misses, scandals, and extra. I recall a very memorable interview, in 2017, just a few days shy of the then-pregnant Jenner’s twentieth birthday. We had been chatting at matriarch Kris Jenner’s residence, and Kylie’s group was adamant that the piece publish whereas she was nonetheless 19 so she may very well be positioned as a teenage entrepreneur. This was throughout peak Kylie-beauty mania, pre-Fenty, whereas Glossier was nonetheless a reasonably tiny firm and earlier than Hailey was a Bieber. Kylie and Kris “opened their books for me” and shared some gross sales figures from Kylie Cosmetics’ first 18 months in enterprise, they usually had been among the wildest numbers I’ve ever seen. It wasn’t till years later, when Coty took a majority stake and shared the model’s revenues, that I realized these figures had been, allegedly, full B.S.
That interview appears like an eternity in the past within the enterprise. In the years since, Jenner has confronted a novel set of challenges, pandemic however. There’s been the surfeit of superstar rivals, after all, but in addition an erosion of the “first-to-market” benefit loved by Kylie, Fenty, and Glossier. Everyone is now following related advertising and marketing, distribution, and product methods. What initially made Kylie Lip Kits revolutionary––utilizing Instagram as a launch pad and a “drop” e-commerce mannequin—is now primarily desk stakes.
The rampant hypothesis, denial, and eventual admission that Jenner had cosmetically enhanced her lips put a dent in her credibility as a vendor of lip merchandise. Customers misplaced belief in her model as soon as they realized that no quantity of liquid lipstick or liner may do the work of filler. And product-wise, Jenner has but to re-create the virality of her Lip Kits, or another hero product for that matter, regardless of Coty having majority possession within the model for practically 5 years (it was rumored final summer time that Jenner was in talks to purchase again the 51 % stake that Coty paid $600 million for in 2019). Maybe that is one purpose that the haters are out in power.

I’ve one other idea. Celebrities are likely to develop up at an accelerated tempo (all that publicity to grownup issues and Kris as your momager), and this phenomenon felt notably acute for Jenner, who went from child sister to mom of two seemingly in a single day. Young shoppers, a lot of whom had been most likely nonetheless in highschool and utilizing their allowance to purchase Jenner’s liquid lipsticks, could have discovered it tougher to attach with the Gen Z founder as soon as she principally began dwelling as a millennial mother.
Beauty tendencies and aesthetics change, too. Demand for the Jenner-patented overly “completed” Instagram face factor tapered off as soon as TikTookay grew to become the social media platform of alternative, and Hailey Bieber grew to become the face of unpolluted woman magnificence. Instagram make-up was out and “glazed donut” pores and skin was in.
Yes, certain, the Kardashians symbolize the worst of American tradition in some ways—clearly—however the household’s penchant for reinvention is extremely admirable. These are relentless individuals, individuals! Skims is an indeniable, runaway success, and Kim Kardashian nonetheless determined to relaunch her magnificence model for a 3rd time (I’m certain a beverage is on the horizon). For Jenner, whose Kylie Cosmetics has but to achieve Skims standing, a reinvention was additionally inevitable. Already, Jenner’s new fragrance, Cosmic, appears to be giving her enterprise a much-needed enhance: After double-digit declines in gross sales for almost all of the final 12 months, in accordance with Earnest Analytics, gross sales on Kylie Cosmetics’ web site had been up near 300 % final month. Maybe Jenner ought to have caught to fragrance all alongside.

That’s it from Rachel and me. You’ll have to attend 24 hours for my Challengers “evaluation.” (In brief, I really like sizzling individuals.)
Until tomorrow,Lauren


R.F.Ok. Oppo Wars

Revealing the Dems’ secret marketing campaign in opposition to Nicole Shanahan.


Need assist? Review our FAQspage or contactus for help. For model partnerships, e-mail [email protected].

You obtained this e-mail since you signed as much as obtain emails from Puck, or as a part of your Puck account related to . To cease receiving this text and/or handle all of your e-mail preferences, click on right here.

Puck is printed by Heat Media LLC. 227 W seventeenth St New York, NY 10011.

Recommended For You